In the aftermath of a supernatural encounter, the investigators stood in the wreckage of Mr. Butters' living room, staring at the mysterious model train set that had somehow summoned a full-sized spectral locomotive crashing through the walls. Soot blackened the ceiling, dents scarred the floor, and the air still carried the acrid smell of something otherworldly. Mr. Butters, visibly shaken and clutching a brandy that Edmund Ashcombe had poured for him, made his wishes perfectly clear: he never wanted to see the train, or the investigators, again.

The party examined the model carefully before agreeing to remove it. It was a high-grade, large-scale set mounted on a rigid six-by-eight-foot board, featuring a locomotive, a tender, and six carriages complete with tiny passengers seated inside. The group noted with unease that the model appeared identical to the spectral locomotive that had torn through the room, and they recalled the haunting image of a man pressing his face against the window of the full-sized train, desperately trying to escape. With Mr. Butters' increasingly frantic insistence ringing in their ears, they arranged a motor taxi large enough to carry the board and departed into the misty London night.

Back at Christopher Smith's substantial residence, the group debated their next move over the small hours of the morning. Edmund Ashcombe, who had nowhere else to go, settled onto the couch while the others argued about whether their missing colleagues — including Doktor Hermann Schneider — might somehow be trapped within the miniature carriages. The debate was inconclusive, and exhaustion eventually won out. They agreed to take the model to the University of London the following morning to conduct a proper experiment in a larger, more controlled space.

On Christmas Eve, Edmund and Christopher transported the unwieldy train board to the university gymnasium, chosen for its flat floor and available power outlets along the walls. While setting up, Edmund managed to recruit Harry, a university caretaker working through the holiday for extra pay, to serve as a witness. Harry was deeply skeptical, declaring flatly that he did not believe in haunted trains, but agreed to watch from a safe distance in exchange for the promise of settling a small wager between Edmund and Christopher.

The train ran. It completed lap after lap around the track in perfect, mundane silence. No spectral passengers materialized, no locomotive tore through the gymnasium walls, and no supernatural phenomena of any kind presented itself. In a last-ditch effort, the investigators reversed the wiring so the train ran in the opposite direction, but the result was the same — ten perfectly ordinary laps. Harry collected his winnings, wished them a Merry Christmas, and returned to his book. The investigators were left staring at a very expensive, very normal toy train.

Frustrated and beginning to wonder if their missing colleagues had staged an elaborate hoax, Edmund telephoned Mr. Butters to check on his well-being and to ask whether there had been anything special about how the train had originally been set up. Butters, who had spent the morning throwing all of his train-related materials into boxes for the charity shop, was not interested in helping. He told them curtly that they should consider themselves lucky and move on, and that he would very much prefer to pretend he had never met any of them. The line went dead.

With the library locked for the Christmas holiday and Harry unwilling to risk his job by letting them in, Christopher quietly picked the lock while Edmund retreated to his office to maintain what he described as plausible deniability. The moment the door swung open, Edmund appeared at his elbow. Together, they navigated the darkened stacks and microfilm readers, searching for records of the 1897 Liverpool Express disaster. The newspapers told a grim story: the crash had occurred at 8:40 in the evening on December 6th, with 87 confirmed dead and 51 persons unaccounted for. Witnesses had reported strange flashes in the sky with no accompanying thunder, and the inquest had been held at the Hertford Assizes under Deputy Coroner Dr. Thomas Wainwright.

As Christmas Eve deepened into night, the investigators made their separate arrangements. Doktor Schneider actually caught the train to Geneva that departed from Charing Cross at 9pm on Christmas Eve. Maddie Wicks telephoned her mother in Winchester, claiming a virus had kept her in London, and endured a tearful conversation about missed presents and disappointed fathers. Christopher's maid prepared beef sandwiches with mustard before departing for her own holiday, and Christopher made the return trip to ensure there was sustenance for those at the university.

That evening, armed with the knowledge that the original crash had occurred at 8:40 PM, Edmund and Christopher returned to the gymnasium and ran the train again, starting at half past eight and continuing well past eleven o'clock. Nothing happened. The train circled its track in the empty gymnasium while London celebrated Christmas Eve outside, and eventually the two men locked the model in Edmund's office and went home. The mystery, it seemed, would have to wait until after the holiday.

Professor Smith, meanwhile, sent urgent telegrams to both Edmund and Christopher, bearing the message that their missing colleagues were alive and well.

Christmas came and went quietly. Christopher drove out to the countryside on the morning of Christmas Day to spend Christmas with his sister Alice and her family.

Doktor Schneider, having caught the train to Geneva, did not spend Christmas in London. Maddie rested and recovered from the head injury she had sustained jumping from the phantom train near Rugby. Edmund spent the day with his family, and Christopher with his sister's household, where nephews and nieces provided a welcome distraction from thoughts of spectral locomotives and doom portals.

On December 27th, the investigators reunited at the University of London, where Maddie sat down with Edmund and recounted everything that had happened aboard the phantom train. She described how Doktor Schneider had been drawn into a trance-like state and walked onto the train, and how she had followed him out of loyalty. The carriages had been filled with revenants — solid, bluish figures that smelled of old wood and moved with the clumsy persistence of animated corpses — and the investigators had fought their way through the train using rotting suitcases, rusty razors, and umbrellas as improvised weapons.

At the far end of the train, they had found Randolph Alexis, a man who had been trapped in the spectral realm for twenty-six years, though he had counted only fifteen based on his "long sleeps." He was utterly insane. He had cannibalized his own son, whose bones and intestines he had fashioned into a grotesque model of the train, carving occult symbols into a human heart to serve as the engine. Doktor Schneider had pushed this terrible device around a makeshift track, making the sounds of a locomotive, while the revenants beat at the carriage doors. Somehow, impossibly, it had worked.

Maddie described how the windows of the spectral train had revealed something extraordinary: visible timelines stretching through the mist beyond the glass, representing the histories of the train and its passengers. When the revenants were thrown from the carriages, their own timelines dissolved into puffs of smoke upon intersecting with others. Alexis had warned them that the space was finite and filling up, and that he had been trying to open a "doom portal" — a gate across time and space — which had caused the original 1897 disaster in the first place. He had been fleeing the Metropolitan Police when he opened it, and the train had been swallowed whole.

The physical train had returned to reality near Rugby and immediately collided with a freight train. Maddie and Doktor Schneider had jumped from the carriages just before the impact, and Maddie had taken a hard blow to the head in the fall. Henry Stanley, the man who had been trapped on the train and had helped them position the model correctly, had also escaped — but what became of Randolph Alexis in the wreckage, no one could say. Professor Smith, upon hearing all of this, abandoned his lifelong skepticism with remarkable enthusiasm, declaring that supernatural events had been confirmed by active, living participants he trusted implicitly.

The investigators' first lead was Henry Stanley himself. They returned to his boarding house in North London, only to find that he had already come and gone — he had appeared briefly, thrown money at the landlady, packed his clothes, and vanished without a forwarding address. The landlady believed he was on the run from the police. The party paid her one pound for Stanley's abandoned collection of train books and departed, with Edmund making a fruitless stop at the local police station where a curt desk officer dismissed his inquiries and refused to act as a message exchange.

Turning their attention to Randolph Alexis, the investigators traveled to Hertford to examine the public inquest records from 1897. The coroner's files listed the victims of the Liverpool Express disaster along with their home addresses, and there among the names was Randolph Alexis — of Golders Green. Further research in the university library revealed that Alexis had been an alleged murderer and performer in magical circles, wanted by the Metropolitan Police for the killing of a man named Edward Gray. He had been fleeing justice when the train disappeared, and was presumed to have died in the crash.

Back in London, the party consulted a telephone directory at their hotel and found three listings for the name Alexis in Golders Green. They agreed to meet at Golders Green station the following morning at ten o'clock, and on the morning of December 29th, the three investigators arrived at the first address on their list. The door was answered by an elderly woman in her seventies named Beatrice — Betty — Alexis, the widow of Randolph himself.

Betty was weary of questions about her husband's alleged crimes, but the mention of a model train set her at ease. She confirmed that her son Albert, an industrial chemist, had built a model of the very train his father had disappeared on — though he had refused to tell her why. Albert had subsequently vanished as well, and his possessions had eventually been returned to her. She led the investigators up to a dark attic filled with boxes, where they discovered six handwritten diaries and notebooks belonging to both Randolph and Albert, filled with text, diagrams, and glued-in newspaper cuttings. A lamp was accidentally broken in the darkness, and Maddie paid for it without complaint.

Betty agreed to lend the diaries to the investigators after Edmund provided his professional card from the University of London as a guarantee of their return. The party descended from the attic with the six volumes tucked carefully under their arms, the first tangible link to the occult knowledge that had sent a train hurtling through the walls of time and space. Somewhere in those pages, they hoped, lay the answers to what Randolph Alexis had truly been attempting — and what it might mean that his son had tried to follow him. The New Year's Eve gathering at Professor Smith's home was only days away, and the investigators had much to discuss.